Yeah I agree, Spotify won't lead the way. Was just using that as an "imagine this" for easy context.
Opportunity for someone new to prove the value of the use-case! Either Spotify catches on and follows suit, or gets left behind as another Blockbuster.
I think all the problems you describe with Spotify are a result of stagnant experimentation in the space caused by walled gardens.
Yes, better social tools for sharing are an uncracked nut. I blame it on lack of opportunity & incentive for experimentation due to the rent seeking of a closed social graph. We peaked at the mix-tape and haven't innovated since.
New user behaviors are erupting left and right on Farcaster due to it offering space for this experimentation.
Music will be the same once a composable social graph is available!